Increasing melee damage

[sjoerdtim]

Hello.
There's been some discussions about melee attacks being weaker than ranged (compared to how they should be), and I feel like this is a good point.

My primary idea would be giving sharpness to every class' melee weapon if they voted. This would only make melee stronger for about 40% of the players, and not increase archery (but still help archers by giving a wooden sword of sharp 1 to them)

My secondary idea, is adding 1 heart to every hit done by a melee attack.
This means directly by weapon, and with a tool that isn't hand, bow, ladder or blocks.

This wouldn't help archers, and still make all melee classes a bit stronger.
A problem with this is that players don't actually see it, and may think attacks do more damage than they should do and accuse people of hacking. (As normal damage doesn't add that heart)

Please vote on this poll to help us get the information we need.

 

[MetObij]

I personally think that we should first implant sharpness 1, see how it goes, and then think about adding +1 health from each meleé attack.
y u no link D:

 

[sjoerdtim]

y u no link D:

I evil

 

[Pythonawe]

I think just 1 heart regained on each kill is good. Maybe sharpness, depending if it becomes to OP.

 

[MetObij]

[quote user_id="2931363" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/Mr_CookieSmurf/74.png" name="Mr_CookieSmurf"]y u no link D:

I evil[/quote]

*plot twist intensifies*

 

[sjoerdtim]

[quote user_id="960266" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/sjoerdtim/74.png" name="sjoerdtim"]

y u no link D:

I evil

*plot twist intensifies*[/quote]

 

[GymLeaderVolkner]

death to cat memes

 

[Kordianthegreat]

I think that you should also have voting for health boost (Basically, adding
2 hearts to the 10 hearts for a total of 12 hearts not to use full for archer, but useful
for swordsman, FOR THEY WHO SHALL NOT BE NAMED, HAVE
STOLEN 2 OF OUR MAPS, I THINK IT IS FITTING
TO STEAL THIS FROM THEM!

 

[MetObij]

[quote user_id="2931363" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/Mr_CookieSmurf/74.png" name="Mr_CookieSmurf"]

[quote user_id="2931363" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/Mr_CookieSmurf/74.png" name="Mr_CookieSmurf"]y u no link D:

I evil

*plot twist intensifies*[/quote]

[/quote]

That's one creepy cat

 

[sjoerdtim]

I think that you should also have voting for health boost (Basically, adding
2 hearts to the 10 hearts for a total of 12 hearts not to use full for archer, but useful
for swordsman, FOR THEY WHO SHALL NOT BE NAMED, HAVE
STOLEN 2 OF OUR MAPS, I THINK IT IS FITTING
TO STEAL THIS FROM THEM!

Adding extra hearts kinda removes the simplicated feel imo, just like adding regen.
Sharpness seems to be most popular, will discuss with staff.

 

[Mark2282]

Archery is kinda ruined already so why would you make soldiers syronger now?

 

[Pythonawe]

Tim would trolls also get it? that is so unfair because 1 sharpness added with strength equals an extra 1 sharpness. Trolls are already OP, this would make them even worse.

 

[Evakobold]

Archery is kinda ruined already so why would you make soldiers syronger now?

No, now its realistic. Where 2 arrows per second would not be possible in the world and those arrows wouldn't knock you back at all. Its better that way. Archers are not supposed to be effective at close range.

 

[Boneknapper74]

yay sharpness 1 for voters!

 

[Anaaron]

Sharpness 1 for voters is good, But not for troll's they're already OP.

Archery is kinda ruined already so why would you make soldiers syronger now?

Evak's right, do you think in LOTR archers were able to load their Arrow and shoot it in a time span of .5 seconds? No way, 2 second shots are far more realistic and even then that would be master archers who have incredible gifts/and or experience.

 

[sjoerdtim]

Sharpness 1 for voters is good, But not for troll's they're already OP.
[quote user_id="6836612" avatar="https://s3.amazonaws.com/files.enjin.com/187965/site_logo/medium.png" name="Mark2282"]Archery is kinda ruined already so why would you make soldiers syronger now?

Evak's right, do you think in LOTR archers were able to load their Arrow and shoot it in a time span of .5 seconds? No way, 2 second shots are far more realistic and even then that would be master archers who have incredible gifts/and or experience.[/quote]
Trolls don't get sharpness 1 for voting.

 

[Rahdgar]

Sharpness 1 for voters is good, But not for troll's they're already OP.
Evak's right, do you think in LOTR archers were able to load their Arrow and shoot it in a time span of .5 seconds? No way, 2 second shots are far more realistic and even then that would be master archers who have incredible gifts/and or experience.

[quote user_id="960266" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/sjoerdtim/74.png" name="sjoerdtim"]Trolls don't get sharpness 1 for voting.[/quote]
YAAAAAASSSSSSSSS thanks for the no troll sharpness, we love you Tim!
And for Anaaron, LEGOLAS

 

[Guest]

Archery is kinda ruined already so why would you make soldiers syronger now?

No, Mark, it's not ruined. You can't arrowspam, that's it, if you can't arch without arrowspamming, you're not a real archer.

 

[Anaaron]

[quote user_id="10631667" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/Anaaron/74.png" name="Anaaron"]Sharpness 1 for voters is good, But not for troll's they're already OP.
Evak's right, do you think in LOTR archers were able to load their Arrow and shoot it in a time span of .5 seconds? No way, 2 second shots are far more realistic and even then that would be master archers who have incredible gifts/and or experience.

[quote user_id="960266" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/sjoerdtim/74.png" name="sjoerdtim"]Trolls don't get sharpness 1 for voting.[/quote]
YAAAAAASSSSSSSSS thanks for the no troll sharpness, we love you Tim!
And for Anaaron, LEGOLAS[/quote]
My point exactly! but he has like, gifts 5 times better than anyone else plus a ton of experience so i'll give him about 1 second to load his bow. ^_^

 

[fj333]

ehm, tim when are you planing to remove troll sharpness?