• Make sure to read the forum rules before creating a new thread or commenting on someone else's thread. The forum rules can be read on this page.

Troll post-1.9

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tobberz

Tobberz

Network Owner
Staff member
Network Owner
As much as I hate to go the effort of making a thread about this... it is pretty important. There is no point in having a class on siege which is useless.
Let me outline my (and other's) main complaints about troll:

1) It is unimaginably weak. It deals 1 damage to longbeard on charged shot. Each shot takes 3 seconds to load. Which means that it would take half a minute to kill a longbeard, excluding the disproportionately large regen non-trolls get. Which leads me onto my next point...

2) Regen. Either give trolls the same regen as everyone else, or decrease everyone else's.

3) Resistance. All semblance of Trolls being tanks has been eliminated. A troll can be wiped out in four shots from an archer... someone even said they received four hearts damage from a single shot once, while playing troll. This is simply preposterous. The same thing goes for melee... leading me on to:

4) Troll vs swordsman fights are ridiculous. A swordsman is just as powerful, if not more powerful, than a troll (taking into account troll's measly damage and swords relative supersonic hitrate). If trolls are going to be weaker than swordsman, remove the troll cap at least!

I hope you understand my exasperation :P

p.s: Miho lost a melee fight as a half troll vs an archer....
 
meh, troll has been OP for a long time not it has to be nerfed and then after a year it can be balanced,
 
fj333 said:
meh, troll has been OP for a long time not it has to be nerfed and then after a year it can be balanced,
Click to expand...
Uhm that isn't how it works. If white people enslave Africans for 300 years, that doesn't mean that Africans can enslave white people for another 300 years....
 
Tobberz said:
[quote user_id="6858712" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/fj333/74.png" name="fj333"]meh, troll has been OP for a long time not it has to be nerfed and then after a year it can be balanced,
Click to expand...
Uhm that isn't how it works. If white people enslave Africans for 300 years, that doesn't mean that Africans can enslave white people for another 300 years....[/quote]
this is how league of legends works kek
 
I think troll should either be tanky and deal low damage or be squishy and do high damage. Having both is OP and was the reason why so many people switched to using archer in 1.8. I would prefer the tanky low damage route.
 
Tanky and low damage? A troll in LOTR can take down a bloody stone column with a club. If anything, they be high damage, high resist, low armor, weak weapon (in terms of durability) and relativly rare on maps like Helm's or Moria.
 
And an archer in LOTR can 1 shot people but you dont see people suggesting that. Why? Because it is anti-fun. Same applies to this. Gameplay > Lore.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top