Thorin was horrible and greedy, he deserved death. All he wanted has a great city and gold, and to be the king of that city. He got what was coming for him.
-
Make sure to read the forum rules before creating a new thread or commenting on someone else's thread. The forum rules can be read on this page.
Elves or Dwarves
- Thread starter YianniC
- Start date
- Status
He wanted the best for his people. He was sick of them being nomads and decided to recapture their city
That's ridicules, Thorin tried to give a home to the people who lost it.
He succeeded. He's not greedy at all, Thorin is the best leader I've seen of the dwarves.
He saves his people, and lead them into victory.
Did I miss the part where they sailed to America? It's called middle earth for a reason, ITS NOT EARTH!
Since when did the Grey Havens become America...? If the Grey Havens are ANYTHING like America, those elves are in for a rude surprise.
Yes they are in for a surprise as us Americans love Dwarves.
First, u mean elves. Second, r u trying to call Erlond stupid. I think he knew 99% of the languages in middle earth, ppl from miles away come to him for advise. Thror was stupid, all the dwarves where. Greedy stupid strong fat ugly and cared nothing for others. Did the dwarves come helping Frodo ( Ignore Gimli, he was decent ) no, they didn't. And didn't Bilbo out smart smaug and save Thorin and the company many times? yes. Dwarves didn't help at all in the war of the ring. ( Again, Gimli did ) So who is ur hero now, dwarvish fans???[/quote]
You are much wrong the dwarves did help in the war of the ring ever heard of lotr war in the north.
Don't forget when the dwarves awoken Durin's Bane, Or the Balrog of Moria, once awoken, the Balrog killed the dwarves and even half of Lorien, So the dwarves did more than you think, I like dwarves more (just for how they are) but voted for elves, they were the first race, knew more magic, and Btw, Elrond was more of a master of the sword, not bow
The Lotr War in the North story was made up, just as BFME2 campaign was made up ( I know this since I played both of the games and still have them), the northern battles were made due to nothing much written about the north, when the war of the ring was in the south, Still the dwarves were in a war at the time recently, so they went to the mines to stay out of it (Cowardly, but maybe they needed to, lets say, regroup, rebuild, after the earlier war).
They sailed to the undying lands.
Also, the sieging of Dale and Erebor during the war of the ring was the most important battle after the battle of pelennor fields.
200.000 easterlings vs 20.000 men and dwarves
The men and dwarves held off 100.000 of them and then the ring got destroyed.
Dain II and Bard were slayed during the process, but the elves of Mirkwood didn't even help to defend Middle-Earth.
Also, the sieging of Dale and Erebor during the war of the ring was the most important battle after the battle of pelennor fields.
200.000 easterlings vs 20.000 men and dwarves
The men and dwarves held off 100.000 of them and then the ring got destroyed.
Dain II and Bard were slayed during the process, but the elves of Mirkwood didn't even help to defend Middle-Earth.
Exactly, other than legolas(who rocks) the mirkwood elves are greedy, frauds. A real elf helps everyone, instead of lock them. Up
An eleven sword is a hadafang
Ahh, but you guys are forgetting the final battle of the War in the North: the march on Dol Guldur, in which all of the elves definitely took part in.
Elf logic when dwarves are in peril screw them.When anything else is in peril here we come.
Say what you want... the poll does not lie.
polls can be biased.
- Status