Make Osgiliath a Flag Map
Osgiliath simply does not work as a gold map.
The Problems:- It is too large.
- There are far too many different ways to go, and places to hide. Compare it to Moria Gold, for instance.
- Adding to this, you can't see the objective from the other end, as in Moria Gold. It is generally more confusing.
- It is the only map which results in large scale server vacation when it starts.
The Solution:
- Make it a gold map. Below is a picture of my proposition for a smaller flag map, but one which would still be enjoyable. I remember that even in the dying days of old EW - with very few players - after the bridge, Osgiliath was one of the map that still worked quite well.
- The blue points are those which Gondor starts with. The lighter blue are possible/alternative flag positions.
Map:
I hope you understand my concerns! Osgiliath does simply not suit the gold style. Now I understand that Tim wants to diversify this server - by having less CTF maps - however, keeping Osgiliath as a Gold map is simply counterproductive.
This does not mean I want Osgiliath removed! As far as I can see, repurposing it (as soon as possible) would be by far the best course of action.
Tell me what you think!