• Make sure to read the forum rules before creating a new thread or commenting on someone else's thread. The forum rules can be read on this page.

New Trailer for the 3rd Hobbit

ThuBioNerd said:
Are you saying stuff is ok in the books but not in the movies?
Click to expand...
The video gives critism on the movie, not the books.
It's all about the movie and as they said before, they don't count any book info for it.
 
They were criticizing things in the movie that happened in the books. If they dislike one they must dislike the other.
 
ThuBioNerd said:
They were criticizing things in the movie that happened in the books. If they dislike one they must dislike the other.
Click to expand...
What you are saying is just total bs.
Peter Jackson changed loads of things from the books, any bad thing of the books could be changed just as well.
It's not an excuse to say "it is in the books", because this is about the movies and has NOTHING to do with the books.
 
CptBlockbeard said:
The only thing I don't like about the new Hobbit trilogy is the excessive use of CGI and generally stupid action sequences. The fight in Goblin Town was completely fine in my opinion, but the barrel scene in The Desolation of Smaug made me facepalm for hours - it was horribly improbable and comical in such a way that it was almost impossible to watch. Hopefully this film's battle scenes will be better!
Click to expand...
ikr the dragon fight the dwarves was the worst. "lets make a giant gold dwarf statue while a dragon is trying to catch us!"
IF they went that far out of the tunnel WHY DIDN"T THEY RUN BACK UP IT
i wonder how Kili and Fili die. it seems they don't go to the lonely mountain. maybe they just burn up in lake town? but its not the battle of 5 armies yet so maybe they catch up before it.
 
Kili stayed behind, while Fili went with the rest. But yeah, Kili is most likely going to arrive at the battleground with the Laketown me and the elves.
 
EnderNicky said:
Kili stayed behind, while Fili went with the rest. But yeah, Kili is most likely going to arrive at the battleground with the Laketown me and the elves.
Click to expand...
Fili staid in Laketown as well, but in the trailer we see them get back to Erebor, so they don't die in the fire.
 
sjoerdtim said:
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]They were criticizing things in the movie that happened in the books. If they dislike one they must dislike the other.
Click to expand...
What you are saying is just total bs.
Peter Jackson changed loads of things from the books, any bad thing of the books could be changed just as well.
It's not an excuse to say "it is in the books", because this is about the movies and has NOTHING to do with the books.[/quote]

When will you f*cking understand what I am saying. You know what, I give up. You are literally saying the same thing over and over and over and over and over...
 
sjoerdtim said:
[quote user_id="7131358" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/EnderNicky/74.png" name="EnderNicky"]
Kili stayed behind, while Fili went with the rest. But yeah, Kili is most likely going to arrive at the battleground with the Laketown me and the elves.
Click to expand...
Fili staid in Laketown as well, but in the trailer we see them get back to Erebor, so they don't die in the fire.
[/quote]
Kili and fili stayed in lake town in the movie. i wonder how Thorin/fili/kili die in the movies.
 
ThuBioNerd said:
[quote user_id="960266" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/sjoerdtim/74.png" name="sjoerdtim"]
ThuBioNerd said:
They were criticizing things in the movie that happened in the books. If they dislike one they must dislike the other.
Click to expand...
What you are saying is just total bs.
Peter Jackson changed loads of things from the books, any bad thing of the books could be changed just as well.
It's not an excuse to say "it is in the books", because this is about the movies and has NOTHING to do with the books.
Click to expand...

When will you f*cking understand what I am saying. You know what, I give up. You are literally saying the same thing over and over and over and over and over...[/quote]
Maybe that's because you keep saying the same thing that is total bs?
You are the one who doesn't understand, because you require me to post it over and over and over and still don't realize what I say is true...
 
Dude. Something happens in the books, then they put it in the movie. People criticize the thing that they see in the movie. If they don't like that scene then it means they don't like it in the book (this is assuming it's unabridged, which I was referring to). Thus they are complaining, indirectly, about the book, and thus J.R.R. Tolkien.
 
ThuBioNerd said:
Dude. Something happens in the books, then they put it in the movie. People criticize the thing that they see in the movie. If they don't like that scene then it means they don't like it in the book (this is assuming it's unabridged, which I was referring to). Thus they are complaining, indirectly, about the book, and thus J.R.R. Tolkien.
Click to expand...
i call BS (even though i didn't read the whole thing). people these days. always saying movies are bad. why thubionerd? why do you say the movie is bad because it has 3 parts!!!
jk XD lol
 
sjoerdtim said:
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]
sjoerdtim said:
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]They were criticizing things in the movie that happened in the books. If they dislike one they must dislike the other.
Click to expand...
What you are saying is just total bs.
Peter Jackson changed loads of things from the books, any bad thing of the books could be changed just as well.
It's not an excuse to say "it is in the books", because this is about the movies and has NOTHING to do with the books.
Click to expand...

When will you f*cking understand what I am saying. You know what, I give up. You are literally saying the same thing over and over and over and over and over...[/quote]
Maybe that's because you keep saying the same thing that is total bs?
You are the one who doesn't understand, because you require me to post it over and over and over and still don't realize what I say is true...[/quote]
Over and over...
 
Lagy_Paladin said:
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]Dude. Something happens in the books, then they put it in the movie. People criticize the thing that they see in the movie. If they don't like that scene then it means they don't like it in the book (this is assuming it's unabridged, which I was referring to). Thus they are complaining, indirectly, about the book, and thus J.R.R. Tolkien.
Click to expand...
i call BS (even though i didn't read the whole thing). people these days. always saying movies are bad. why thubionerd? why do you say the movie is bad because it has 3 parts!!!
jk XD lol[/quote]

When I started reading that I was like OMG FFUUUUUU

Then I was like >.>
 
ThuBioNerd said:
[quote user_id="4289752" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/Lagy_Paladin/74.png" name="Lagy_Paladin"]
ThuBioNerd said:
Dude. Something happens in the books, then they put it in the movie. People criticize the thing that they see in the movie. If they don't like that scene then it means they don't like it in the book (this is assuming it's unabridged, which I was referring to). Thus they are complaining, indirectly, about the book, and thus J.R.R. Tolkien.
Click to expand...
i call BS (even though i didn't read the whole thing). people these days. always saying movies are bad. why thubionerd? why do you say the movie is bad because it has 3 parts!!!
jk XD lol
Click to expand...

When I started reading that I was like OMG FFUUUUUU

Then I was like >.>[/quote]
Oh dear gone be a flame war about this
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top