• Make sure to read the forum rules before creating a new thread or commenting on someone else's thread. The forum rules can be read on this page.

Old EW RP Argument Thread! :D

CptBlockbeard

New member
We've been told to, 'Move this discussion to another thread more appropriate for it. This thread is for screenshots and tiny bits of memories to accompany them only. Cease, or I shall be forced to lock this thread.' Oh well, now where were we? Oh yes I remember, something about the allegiances of factions and some fantasy 'terrorism'! Now c'mon, let's fight over something that happened over a year ago just to try and relive moments that won't happen again! *cheesy music montage*
 
Not gonna fight for the sake of fighting, but it was actually just 8 months ago.
 
Really 8 months?! Wow, possibly due to current situation that feels like a real long time ago.
 
something about ilthilien vs blackflye ?
I kind of like reading arguments
so.. I think ilthilien could totally take on all of the rest of the server
( :furious: blackflye or what ever you call it)
 
NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER
 
NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER

NO YOU IDIOT NO THEU WERE THE WORST AT ROLEPLAYING!
 
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER

NO YOU IDIOT NO THEU WERE THE WORST AT ROLEPLAYING![/quote]
Screenie taken by cookie shows how good you were... :P
Ilthilien sucked!
 
[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER

NO YOU IDIOT NO THEU WERE THE WORST AT ROLEPLAYING![/quote]
that would explain why his advernture roleplay ish game isn't turning out to well :P
 
NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER

You're just annoyed because you tried to arrest us with nothing but a stick when we had full diamond armor! xP
 
We were not even close to done are walls were gonna be boss at Edessa BOSS thick, high, full of sand/gravel. There was going to be a tower that went up to build height and down to bedrock Edessa was going to be way better than anything else.
 
something about ilthilien vs blackflye ?
I kind of like reading arguments
so.. I think ilthilien could totally take on all of the rest of the server
( :furious: blackflye or what ever you call it)

It could. The costs would be high though.

[quote user_id="3751908" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/ThuBioNerd/74.png" name="ThuBioNerd"]NO MAD THEY DIDN'T THEY WERE THE ONLY NATION WHERE MORE THAN HALF OF THEIR MEMBERS COULD ROLEPLAY.

I propose a truce between former Iths and former Fyres (Didn't wanna say Blacks). This truce is, let's be friends and

BEAT UP ON REDDAGGER[/quote]

We kinda truced already now that there is nothing to argue on.
[quote user_id="6486074" avatar="https://cravatar.eu/helmavatar/akam7912/74.png" name="akam7912"]I can't believe I built a town right across from Ilthilien. If EW RP does reopen, I will make a Reddagger/Arnor combined faction.[/quote]

Well I am not sure reddagger is under your command...

yea and akams town would have lost to anyone.

It might not. It might disintegrate before anyone's army reaches it :D

On a more practical note this is how most empires fall apart, this happened to both Kargeth and Ilthilien (Ilthilien still standing though)
 
Kargeth probably would have survived me and akam basically just quit it. Ithilien on the other hand was quit just like kargeth until u got sweet talked by akam.
 
Kargeth probably would have survived me and akam basically just quit it. Ithilien on the other hand was quit just like kargeth until u got sweet talked by akam.

No, Kargeth fell even before EW ended and only Edessa was established. Edessa was its own settlement and not exactly Kargeth, compared to Ilthilien and Blackfyre which had multiple settlements and were much bigger than Edessa.

The difference is that akam did not have any knowledge of how rp would work when he founded Kargeth (I observed Blackfyre for a bit before casting my lots with dwight and Ilthilien, then a very small faction about the size of reddagger), and he was too hotheaded. Obviously Blackfyre and Ilthilien were not happy.
 
Back
Top